Aaron Judge, one of the most feared sluggers in Major League Baseball, lit up the 2024 regular season with staggering numbers. His towering home runs, his laser-like focus, and his innate ability to read pitches made him an almost unstoppable force in the batter's box. But as the postseason arrived, Judge, much like many right-handed power hitters before him, encountered a challenge that even his immense talent has struggled to overcome. The devastating slider and splitter, thrown by elite right-handed pitchers, began to tie him up. Pitch after pitch, low and breaking away from his swing, left him grasping at air. His postseason performance, especially in the World Series, has been a tale of swings and misses — not because of a lack of effort but because of the deception and artistry behind these two pitches.

To understand why right-handed hitters like Judge struggle with these pitches, we must first delve into the origins and mechanics of the slider and splitter, their differences, and why they are so challenging to right-handed hitters. We must also explore the curveball, a pitch that is similarly tricky but not quite as devastating when compared to the slider and splitter against righty bats.

The slider and splitter are two pitches that, while sharing some similarities, diverge in their break, speed, and the way they deceive batters.

The slider was popularized in the early 20th century, gaining prominence as pitchers looked for ways to add a more subtle breaking ball to their arsenal than the looping curveball. The slider’s hallmark is its sharp, late-breaking movement. It looks like a fastball coming out of the pitcher’s hand, but as it approaches the plate, it veers sideways, often downward, fooling the batter into swinging at what appears to be a hittable pitch.

In contrast, the splitter, or split-finger fastball, gained recognition later, in the 1970s and 80s, thanks to pitchers like Bruce Sutter. A splitter is thrown similarly to a fastball, but with the fingers split apart on the ball. As the ball reaches home plate, it suddenly drops, mimicking the downward motion of a sinker, though often with more pronounced break. The splitter tends to induce swings and misses because it appears as a fastball for most of its flight but then falls off the table, leaving hitters swinging at air.

While the curveball is also known for its break, it behaves differently compared to sliders and splitters. A curveball has a more pronounced, looping motion, breaking downward from a higher arc. This pitch, often slower than a slider or splitter, has been a staple for generations of pitchers.

​Curveballs can still baffle hitters, but for right-handed hitters, it’s generally the pitch's slower speed and predictability that make it less dangerous than a slider or splitter. While the curveball breaks down, a slider breaks laterally — and that lateral movement, especially when breaking away from a right-handed batter, makes it harder to track.

For a hitter to fully understand why these pitches are so tricky, they need to understand the grip and mechanics involved in delivering them.

1. Slider: To throw a slider, a pitcher places the fingers slightly off-center on the ball, closer to the seams, with the thumb underneath. The wrist remains firm as the pitcher releases the ball, causing it to spin rapidly. This rapid spin creates a sharp, late break, typically to the pitcher’s glove side. The speed of the slider, combined with its sudden horizontal break, is what makes it so difficult to hit — especially for right-handed hitters. As the ball moves away from their bat, the swing often trails behind, leading to weak contact or complete misses.

2. Splitter: A splitter grip involves placing the index and middle fingers wide apart on either side of the seams while the thumb rests underneath the ball. The key here is the fastball-like arm motion. The pitch comes out of the hand like a fastball, but the wide grip reduces backspin, causing the ball to drop sharply as it approaches the plate. Right-handed hitters, expecting the ball to stay on a straight plane, often swing above the pitch as it dips out of the strike zone.

3. Curveball: For a curveball, the pitcher grips the ball with the middle finger along a seam and the index finger resting beside it. The thumb helps with control underneath. Unlike the slider or splitter, a curveball requires the pitcher to snap their wrist downward at release, imparting top-spin on the ball. The result is a looping, slow pitch that drops as it approaches the batter. For right-handed hitters, a curveball breaking down is easier to track compared to the slider or splitter that moves laterally or unpredictably.

For right-handed batters, particularly power hitters like Aaron Judge, the struggle with sliders and splitters boils down to timing and tracking. These pitches, especially when thrown by right-handed pitchers, move in a way that exploits a right-hander’s natural swing path. A slider, breaking low and away, moves outside the reach of their bat. A splitter drops out of sight, often too late for the batter to adjust.

The right-handed hitter's challenge is heightened by the fact that both pitches come out of the pitcher’s hand looking like a fastball — the pitch every power hitter loves to crush. As soon as they commit to the swing, the ball is no longer where they expect it to be.

​In contrast, a curveball’s movement is more recognizable. Its slower speed and arc give hitters more time to adjust, making it less deadly to right-handed batters, though still effective in certain counts.

Max Scherzer – Known for pinpoint control and a sharp slider that dominates right-handers.
Jacob deGrom – His fast, late-breaking slider is nearly unhittable.
Corey Kluber – Master of the sweeping slider, especially effective against right-handed hitters.
Pedro Martinez – His slider had wicked movement, especially in high-pressure situations.
Roy Halladay – Halladay’s slider was part of his dominant repertoire, often freezing right-handed hitters.

David Cone – Cone's splitter was instrumental in his success, particularly in tight situations.
​Hideo Nomo – Known for his splitter that kept hitters off balance throughout his career.
​Shohei Ohtani – His splitter drops off the table, fooling even the best hitters.
​Roger Clemens – Complemented his overpowering fastball with a lethal splitter.
Bruce Sutter – Pioneered the splitter, making it one of MLB's most effective pitches.

Bert Blyleven – Often regarded as having the best curveball in MLB history, fooling batters for decades.
Justin Verlander – Combines velocity with a devastating power curve that drops sharply.
Adam Wainwright – Known for consistently fooling batters with his big, looping curve.
Zack Greinke – His slow, looping curveball continues to baffle hitters.
Dwight Gooden – His 12-to-6 curveball was feared and helped him dominate in the 1980s.

So how do successful right-handed hitters adjust to these pitches? The key is discipline and pitch recognition.

1. Lay Off the Slider: Right-handed hitters who are adept at handling sliders have learned to wait for the slider to start its break before committing to their swing. This means focusing on pitches up in the zone, where sliders are less effective. Hitters like Mookie Betts are patient and wait for the ball to flatten out before swinging.​

2. Recognize the Splitter Early: Successful hitters, like Miguel Cabrera, focus on the pitcher's release point. If they recognize a splitter early, they stay back and adjust to the downward movement. This patience allows them to avoid swinging over the pitch and instead wait for it to drop into the strike zone.​

3. Stay Off the Curveball: Against curveballs, right-handed hitters with good vision and timing, like Mike Trout, track the spin of the ball out of the pitcher’s hand. Curveballs tend to have a noticeable topspin, allowing hitters to make more informed decisions about when to swing.

For Aaron Judge, the solution lies in selective aggression. Judge, known for his power, needs to resist chasing sliders and splitters early in counts. If he can lay off those pitches, he’ll force pitchers to throw more fastballs in the zone — where his power thrives. By focusing on pitch recognition and discipline, Judge can start turning his at-bats around, even against the trickiest sliders and splitters.
​
​Aaron Judge’s struggles with sliders and splitters are not unique, but if he can master the discipline that hitters before him have used to combat these pitches, he may be able to turn his postseason around and reclaim his dominance.
​
​For Aaron Judge, or any elite hitter, recognizing a breaking pitch like a slider, splitter, or curveball is key to making solid contact and avoiding chasing pitches out of the strike zone. To improve pitch recognition, Judge can focus on several critical factors in the pitcher’s mechanics and cues:

One of the earliest indicators of a breaking pitch is the grip the pitcher uses. For example:

Slider: The pitcher will grip the ball with fingers slightly off-center, closer to the seams.
Splitter: The grip will have the pitcher’s index and middle fingers spread apart on either side of the ball.
Curveball: The pitcher may grip the ball with their middle finger along a seam, and the wrist snap might be more pronounced.

However, recognizing the grip is incredibly challenging in real-time since the pitcher often hides the ball in their glove. Yet, sharp hitters with a keen eye may pick up subtle cues if they catch a glimpse of the grip during the pitcher’s windup or release.

Arm angle can be a vital cue in distinguishing fastballs from breaking pitches:

Slider: Often thrown from a more 3/4 arm slot, which allows the pitcher to generate horizontal and downward movement. Judge might look for this specific arm action, which is different from the over-the-top motion of a fastball.
Curveball: The arm angle for a curveball can vary, but there is usually a visible wrist snap or distinct, exaggerated motion as the pitcher releases the ball to create the topspin needed for the break.
Splitter: The arm action for a splitter looks similar to a fastball, making it difficult to identify based on arm angle alone, which is why batters often struggle with it. However, a slight drop in velocity may clue Judge into the splitter being thrown.

The release point is another critical visual cue:

Fastballs: Often released higher and with a more direct path to the plate.

Breaking pitches: Tend to have a slightly lower release point as the pitcher adjusts to generate spin and break on the ball. Sliders, for example, tend to come out of the hand with a subtle sideways motion rather than directly forward.

By focusing on where the pitcher releases the ball, Judge can anticipate the type of pitch coming. A lower release often indicates breaking pitches like a slider or curveball.

Recognizing the spin and velocity of the ball can help Judge differentiate between a fastball and a breaking pitch:

Spin: Breaking pitches like sliders and curveballs have distinctive spin patterns. A slider has a tighter, more diagonal spin, while a curveball produces more visible topspin. Elite hitters are trained to pick up on this spin immediately after release.

​Velocity: Breaking pitches are almost always slower than fastballs. A fastball can come in at 95-100 mph, but a slider or curveball will often be in the 80-90 mph range, depending on the pitcher. Judge needs to adjust his timing once he identifies the lower velocity coming out of the pitcher’s hand.

In addition to visual cues, Judge can improve his ability to recognize breaking pitches by studying the pitcher’s tendencies:

Count-Based Tendencies: Many pitchers are more likely to throw breaking pitches in certain counts (e.g., 0-2, 1-2). By understanding when pitchers tend to go to their breaking stuff, Judge can anticipate and adjust his approach.

Matchup History: Analyzing how pitchers have attacked him in previous at-bats can provide clues. For example, if a pitcher has consistently thrown sliders when ahead in the count, Judge can prepare for that.

Video Analysis: Watching video of opposing pitchers can help Judge identify subtle differences in their delivery or arm action when throwing breaking pitches. Being familiar with how a specific pitcher throws his slider, splitter, or curveball can improve real-time recognition.

Finally, Judge’s plate discipline is crucial in combating breaking pitches:

Lay Off Pitches Outside the Zone: Sliders and curveballs often start in the strike zone but break out of it. If Judge can develop the patience to lay off pitches that break low and away, he’ll force pitchers to challenge him in the zone, where he excels.

Zone Awareness: Judge needs to focus on targeting pitches that stay within his power zones and not chase breaking balls that start high and break low or away. Improved discipline means fouling off borderline breaking pitches rather than swinging and missing.

By honing his pitch recognition skills using these strategies, Aaron Judge can improve his ability to handle breaking pitches, avoid bad swings, and increase his overall offensive production, particularly in the postseason.